Sunday, October 30, 2011

The Cube: Green

Acidic Slime
Ant Queen
Arashi, the Sky Asunder
Avenger of Zendikar
Birds of Paradise
Borderland Ranger
Brooding Saurian
Chameleon Colossus
Civic Wayfinder
Cloudthresher
Deranged Hermit
Eternal Witness
Elvish Archdruid
Elvish Piper
Elvish Visionary
Farhaven Elf
Fauna Shaman
Garruk's Packleader
Genesis
Imperious Perfect
Indrik Stomphowler
Joraga Treespeaker
Jugan, the Rising Star
Kodama of the North Tree
Krosan Tusker
Llanowar Elves
Lotus Cobra
Masked Admirers
Master of the Wild Hunt
Mul Daya Channelers
Obstinate Baloth
Ohran Viper
Oracle of Mul Daya
Pelakka Wurm
Priest of Titania
Primeval Titan
Rampaging Baloths
River Boa
Sakura-Tribe Elder
Seedborn Muse
Sylvan Ranger
Terastodon
Thelonite Hermit
Thornling
Thrun, the Last Troll
Uktabi Orangutan
Vengevine
Verdant Force
Verdeloth, the Ancient
Vigor
Wall of Roots
Wickerbough Elder
Wild Mongrel
Wild Nacatl
Wolfbriar Elemental
Woodfall Primus
Yavimaya Elder

Spells:

Channel
Cultivate
Explore
Farseek
Garruk Wildspeaker
Garruk, Primal Hunter
Greater Good
Harmonize
Harrow
Kodama's Reach
Moment's Peace
Natural Order
Nissa Revane
Noxious Revival
Overrun
Primal Command
Rampant Growth
Recollect
Regrowth
Search for Tomorrow
Survival of the Fittest
Squall Line

The Cube: Red

Akroma, Angel of Fury
Blisterstick Shaman
Bogardan Hellkite
Caldera Hellion
Conquering Manticore
Covetous Dragon
Cunning Sparkmage
Dragon Whelp
Ember Hauler
Fire Imp
Flameblast Dragon
Flametongue Kavu
Furystoke Giant
Goblin Artillery
Goblin Chieftain
Goblin Wardriver
Greater Gargadon
Grim Lavamancer
Hellspark Elemental
Hell's Thunder
Hostility
Inferno Titan
Jaya Ballard, Task Mage
Kargan Dragonlord
Kiki-Jiki, Mirror Breaker
Kird Ape
Kuldotha Phoenix
Magus of the Scroll
Manic Vandal
Mogg War Marshal
Obsidian Fireheart
Plated Geopede
Rakka Mar
Ryusei, the Falling Star
Scorched Rusalka
Scourge of Kher Ridges
Shivan Dragon
Siege-Gang Commander
Spikeshot Elder
Taurean Mauler
Tin Street Hooligan
Voracious Dragon
Zo-Zu the Punisher

Spells:

Act of Aggression
Arc Trail
Banefire
Burst Lightning
Chain Lightning
Chandra Ablaze
Chandra, the Firebrand
Chandra Nalaar
Chandra's Outrage
Char
Comet Storm
Cone of Flame
Demonfire
Earthquake
Fireball
Fireblast
Firebolt
Flame Javelin
Flame Wave
Galvanic Blast
Goblin Assault
Hammer of Bogardan
Incinerate
Koth of the Hammer
Lightning Bolt
Magma Jet
Molten Disaster
Red Sun's Zenith
Resounding Thunder
Rift Bolt
Rolling Thunder
Seal of Fire
Searing Blaze
Slagstorm
Staggershock
Tarfire
Word of Seizing


Time to do the compare/contrast with Tom's list:

Goblin Cadets is interesting, but I'm not certain it would make it in as a Red Savannah Lions. Same goes for Goblin Patrol. Jackal Pup did a tour of duty and was largely deemed terrible.

One could legitimately argue that these cards need a vast web of support in order to be good, but this has the fundamental problem of being slot-restrictive. Additionally, super-aggro draft formats tend not to be particularly pleasant (Zendikar), while battle-cruiser Magic is generally enjoyable.

Mogg Fanatic was basically just disappointing: Spikeshot isn't leagues better, but he is more interesting.

Skirk Marauder may actually make it in: I'm not sure why it didn't previously get a slot.

Blood Knight was aesthetically pleasing to have in, but Kargan Dragonlord is just (usually) grossly superior and more interesting.

Hearth Kami is unlikely to get the nod, but if I need additional artifact destruction and don't want to run Ancient Grudge (or already am), it's certainly an option.

Slith Firewalker got cut ages ago and I've never looked back. Given the printing of Stromkirk Noble, I don't think it's likely to ever return.

Ball Lightning, Sedge Sliver and Sulfur Elemental all failed to perform.

Avalanche Riders is tempting largely by virtue of being an invitational card, but I'd probably be inclined to run Goblin Ruinblaster over it due to the Goblin theme.

Blistering Firecat was pretty thoroughly mediocre, Lava Hounds and Skizzik are both slightly underpowered.

Ancient Hydra is interesting, but just didn't do enough. Arc-Slogger can only be activated three times at most, and not worth writing home about.

Genju of the Spires is interesting but too mana-ineffecient, Sulfuric Vortex got lost on its way to a sideboard.

Brute Force is still just Giant Growth, which is still terrible.

There are enough strictly-better versions of Shock already included that it's unlikely to ever return. Sudden Shock's split-second rarely mattered, and there have been a number of sweet burn spells printed since.

Pulse of the Forge is probably a fine card when Red is designed primarily to do a fast 20, but it's not appropriate for my list.

Urza's Rage was cut for Resounding Thunder since the cycling is just much more realistic than the kicker.

Seething Song is an interesting exercise in costing: were it literally a Red Dark Ritual, it'd probably be in. As is, the jump from 3 to 5 is worth the card rarely enough that this languished in sideboards before getting the axe.

Reckless Charge got cut for some actual burn spell, Tribal Flames for something more consistent. (Flame Javelin, I think)

Arc Lightning at instant speed would be an exciting addition, but Staggershock got the slot: Rebound is an interesting take on card advantage, and Arc Trail shaving a mana off the most common mode makes this an unlikely return.

Molten Rain has a fine history, but LD suffers in Limited. The best case is that you color-screw your opponent, which is fairly frustrating. Pillage would probably come in first due to the versatility, anyway.

Wildfire isn't a guaranteed Wrath by any means, and the limited-Armageddon is pretty situational. I'd probably run Boom//Bust over it just because split cards are neat.

The Cube: Black

Creatures:

Anowon, the Ruin Sage
Avatar of Woe
Black Knight
Braids, Cabal Minion
Bloodghast
Coffin Queen
Dark Confidant
Doomed Necromancer
Drana, Kalastria Bloodchief
Dread
Faceless Butcher
Gatekeeper of Malakir
Grave Titan
Graveborn Muse
Guul Draz Assassin
Hand of Cruelty
Hypnotic Specter
Kokusho, the Evening Star
Liliana's Specter
Malakir Bloodwitch
Nekrataal
Nezumi Graverobber
Oona's Prowler
Puppeteer Clique
Royal Assassin
Sheoldred, Whispering One
Skeletal Vampire
Shriekmaw
Skinrender
Tombstalker
Vampire Nighthawk
Visara the Dreadful

Spells:

Animate Dead
Beacon of Unrest
Bitterblossom
Black Sun's Zenith
Chainer's Edict
Consuming Vapors
Corrupt
Cruel Edict
Damnation
Dance of the Dead
Dark Banishing
Dark Ritual
Demonic Tutor
Dismember
Doom Blade
Dread Return
Enslave
Entomb
Executioner's Capsule
Exhume
Eyeblight's Ending
Go for the Throat
Hymn to Tourach
Imperial Seal
Incremental Blight
Liliana Vess
Life's Finale
Makeshift Mannequin
Nameless Inversion
Necromancy
Necropotence
Profane Command
Reanimate
Ribbons of Night
Scepter of Fugue
Seal of Doom
Seize the Soul
Sign in Blood
Slaughter Pact
Smallpox
Sorin Markov
Sudden Death
Tendrils of Corruption
Terror
Vampiric Tutor
Yawgmoth's Bargain
Yawgmoth's Will
Zombify

I've seen a number of Cube lists that try to make Black weenie a legitimate archetype. I've never seen it actually get played, and the end result usually seems to be that Black is basically a splash color for Blue and Green decks. Hand of Cruelty and Black Knight are the only nods to the archetype, and they're perpetually on the chopping block. They carry equipment well, though, and there isn't yet-another-Nekrataal to replace them (yet).

Most of the cuts relative to Tom's list are simply the lack of desire to try to support B weenie (Carnophage, Sarcomancy, Shadow Guildmage, Nantuko Shade), the Shadow (Dauthi) weenies get double damage from also having a keyword that makes them noninteractive.

Skinthinner and Bone Shredder are both candidates, but they're pretty poor 187s. Bane of the Living is somewhat interesting, but is unremarkable as either a creature or Wrath. Phyrexian Scuta is honestly just not compelling as a 4-mana 5/5, and Juzam Djinn (Plague Sliver) isn't much better.

Phyrexian Arena should be in my list, probably over Scepter of Fugue or Cruel Edict.

I prefer Recurring Nightmare in the form of Doomed Necromancer: there's some power level loss, but the the necromancer is generally more interesting. The interactions with the two Survivals are (obviously) a minor bonus, with Enlightened Tutor as the only real loss.

Diabolic Edict was cut on the grounds that it was the only instant-speed Edict and thus just didn't feel right. Now, it's likely that Vicious Hunger will leapfrog both Cruel and Diabolic for the slot.

Smother shouldn't make most lists simply because you now have Doom Blade, Terror and Go For the Throat all at 2.

Tainted Pact is interesting, but it's far too likely to just miss entirely due to hitting multiple basic lands.

Skeletal Scrying may make it in if the Cube grows substantially, but Sign in Blood is currently claiming the one-shot B draw slot.

Duress and Stupor simply weren't strong enough: discard generally is much weaker in Limited.

Living Death probably deserves a slot, likely over Life's Finale. That said, the Cranial Extraction component of Finale is very appealing and very Black.