Tuesday, July 22, 2014

Cube Philosophy

The Magic Online Cube is, like my own, very much in the vein of Tom LaPille's original design: a singleton collection of cards that have a high abstract power level and generally a strong history of performance in at least one format.

This is, obviously, not the only way to construct a Cube, but I believe it leads to interesting results.  Jason Waddell advocates approaching Cube design as Limited set design, which I agree with, although I don't like his designs in the abstract.

For instance, I agree that Channel into Ulamog doesn't maximize the player experience, and that's part of the reason that Channel isn't in my list any more.  The larger reason, though, is that Channel is not a Green card.  Power-level concerns aside, it has an ability that is simply not part of Green's slice of the color pie.  And that concern, ultimately, is why I'm not enamored of Cube designs that try to evoke a particular block, or push certain mechanics, because that is not pure Magic.

Virtually every block has featured cards that stretch the boundaries of the color pie for its present.  Some of those stretches have made their way into the general fabric of the game, most have not.  Basic landcycling, for instance, missed: fetching lands from your library is very Green, and once the concerns of Alara block had passed, the ability more-or-less vanished from the other colors.

I've become increasingly concerned with the color pie correctness of my Cube, and I think it's most of the way there.  There are some underrepresented effects, as well as a few cards that push the boundaries (Damnation, for instance).