Sunday, July 17, 2011

The Cube: White

Creatures:

Accorder Paladin
Admonition Angel
Akroma, Angel of Wrath
Baneslayer Angel
Calciderm
Captain of the Watch
Crovax, Ascendant Hero
Dawnglare Invoker
Eight-and-a-Half Tails
Elite Vanguard
Emeria Angel
Exalted Angel
Eternal Dragon
Flickerwisp
Goldmeadow Harrier
Galepowder Mage
Gideon's Lawkeeper
Hand of Honor
Hokori, Dust Drinker
Isamaru, Hound of Konda
Icatian Javelineers
Knight of the White Orchid
Knight of Meadowgrain
Knight of the Holy Nimbus
Kor Firewalker
Leonin Relic-Warder
Linvala, Keeper of Silence
Loam Lion
Mirror Entity
Mother of Runes
Paladin en-Vec
Purity
Ranger of Eos
Reveillark
Samurai of the Pale Curtain
Savannah Lions
Serra Angel
Sigiled Paladin
Silver Knight
Stoneforge Mystic
Student of Warfare
Sunblast Angel
Sun Titan
Twilight Shepherd
War Priest of Thune
Weathered Wayfarer
Whipcorder
White Knight
Windborn Muse
Yosei, the Morning Star

(non-creatures):

Ajani Goldmane
Austere Command
Armageddon
Balance
Condemn
Day of Judgment
Decree of Justice
Elspeth, Knight-Errant
Elspeth Tirel
Enlightened Tutor
Faiths Fetters
Gideon Jura
Glorious Anthem
Hallowed Burial
Land Tax
Marshal's Anthem
Martial Coup
Oblivion Ring
Pacifism
Planar Cleansing
Parallax Wave
Path to Exile
Prison Term
Sacred Mesa
Spectral Procession
Shining Shoal
Scepter of Dominance
Swords to Plowshares
Wrath of God
Worship

White in my cube has undergone relatively few revisions. The absurd fatties have mostly been on lockdown: of recent printings, only Elesh Norn merits serious consideration. White rarely strays far out of it's section of the color-pie, so there aren't many exclusions on that basis.

Speaking to cards found in Tom LaPille's list and not in mine:

Academy Rector rarely has enough toys to play with to ultimately be worth the deck slot.

Descendant of Kiyomaro, Mystic Crusader, Mageta the Lion, Renewed Faith, Serra Avenger and Leonin Skyhunter were underpowered.

I cut the Soltari weenies (Priest/Monk) because they're almost entirely non-interactive and probably underpowered to boot.

Spectral Lynx is very weird, and somewhat weak, but most importantly it doesn't feel like a White card.


Pristine Angel was arguably underpowered and tended to be either uninteresting or non-interactive. If I was going to expand the size of the cube substantially (to, say, 100), it'd probably make the cut.

Griffin Guide was a relatively recent cut, basically the result of the growing power of equipment. The remaining White enchantments all *do* something: Griffin Guide just resulted in getting 2-for-1'd too regularly. When a card consistently ends up in a sideboard, it tends to get cut as soon as I find a good alternative.

Tithe: White is a creature color. I'd much rather have Weathered Wayfarer than Tithe, especially since Ranger of Eos exists.

Disenchant hasn't been printed in White for so long that it's de facto removed from White's color pie, and basically should be: White is the color of exile, not destruction. There are certainly exceptions but I believe that many of those are the result of the relative complexity of the Exile zone. It's telling that Demystify and Divine Offering are both in Standard right now and Disenchant isn't. (while White is allowed to do both halves of Disenchant, the versatility has shifted towards Green)

Exile is incredibly tempting due to the name, but it's a bit underpowered and the rules text smells far too much of the Silver age of Magic. (complicated for no apparent reason other than arguably balance)

Pulse of the Fields: it did a noble tour of duty in constructed but it's frankly underpowered/uninteresting.

Wing Shards: Storm is a bad mechanic, especially for Limited, and frankly the card was rarely played.

Chastise simply cost far too much. At 1W, it might make the cut.

Cataclysm: The "fixed" Balance. It's definitely interesting, and I periodically consider cutting Planar Cleansing or Hallowed Burial for it. Then I remember that "sacrifice" feels very, very Black and that the art is mediocre at best. Balance gets the go-ahead on sheer power level, and frankly it feels more White. My biggest regret is that this name was spent on this card.

Catastrophe: Interesting, but the only casting worth the cost is for lands: in individual games, you might choose creatures, but in the abstract you're probably running it in your deck as an expensive Armageddon rather than an expensive Wrath. It might get the nod over Planar Cleansing some day, but the reset factor there is very appealing, as is the art.

Ravages of War: look, ma, it's Armageddon! I strongly considered running two visibly different versions of Armageddon and claiming that one was filling in for Ravages (which costs a surprising amount of $), but was persuaded against it. I wouldn't run both Doom Blade and (hypothetical) Blade of Doom in Black, so I'm not going to run Ravages, regardless of how good Armageddon is.

Rout: Instant speed adds some potential play interactions, but Hallowed Burial has the ability to mess with Reanimator decks. Honestly, the "potential play interactions" basically amount to "kill another guy or two", and I think Rout just doesn't bring enough to the table.

Winds of Rath: the enchantment clause is interesting, but because creature enchantments are basically unplayable and will probably continue to be, this also loses out to Hallowed Burial.

Akroma's Vengeance: this is (probably) actually the card most likely to knock Planar Cleansing from the slot, but the cleanliness of "destroy all nonland permanents" is just so appealing. It's a huge credit to the recent core set designs.


No comments:

Post a Comment